Skip to content

Which Yields More in Five Years – Equity SIP or Debentures?

By News Analysis India · · 1 min read

A systematic investment of Rs 1,000 each month can follow two very different paths. In an equity SIP, the money is used to buy shares of listed companies; the portfolio value moves with market sentiment, delivering an average 12‑13 % return over the long run. Some years may see double‑digit gains, while others may record modest or negative performance. Debentures, on the other hand, are loan‑like instruments where the issuing corporation pays a predetermined interest, usually between 9 % and 13 % per annum. Assuming a 10 % annual interest and monthly compounding, the total after five years would be around Rs 96,600, compared with roughly Rs 84,000 for the equity route at a 13 % rate. While debentures provide a more predictable payout, they still carry credit risk if the issuer defaults. The choice depends on how much volatility an investor can stomach and whether they value steady income over potential upside.