Skip to content

JDU Expels Anant Singh; Speaker to Decide His Future

By News Analysis India · · 1 min read

Mokama MLA Anant Singh has been expelled from the Janata Dal (United) for six years, and his primary membership has been terminated with immediate effect. The party has also asked Bihar Assembly Speaker Prem Kumar to disqualify Singh from the assembly under the Tenth Schedule of the Constitution.

According to the party, Singh did not follow its instructions, made objectionable remarks against senior leaders, and campaigned in the Legislative Council election for Jan Suraaj's Anuj Singh rather than JDU's official candidate. The JDU nominee, Neeraj Kumar, was contesting from the Patna Graduates Constituency.

Former MLA Neelam Devi has also been removed from the party for six years over anti-party activities.

Why Expulsion Alone May Not Be Enough

A question now arises whether losing party membership automatically costs Singh his seat. The answer depends on the Tenth Schedule, which was introduced in 1985 through the 52nd Constitutional Amendment to curb defections by legislators and MPs.

The law sets out specific grounds. Voluntarily giving up party membership can lead to disqualification. So can voting against a party whip, or abstaining, without the party condoning it within 15 days. The Speaker holds the authority to decide these questions.

Precedents Matter

In the 1996 G. Viswanathan case against the Tamil Nadu Assembly Speaker, the Supreme Court held that a legislator expelled from a party may still be treated as a member of the party that fielded him. Expulsion, therefore, does not by itself take a legislator outside the anti-defection law.

In the 1994 Ravi S. Naik case against the Union of India, the Supreme Court said voluntarily giving up membership is not limited to resigning. Conduct can support such a conclusion, but it must be backed by credible and reliable evidence.

What Comes Next

Speaker Prem Kumar will examine the recommendation and the material placed before him. His decision will be the final word in the first instance, though it may be open to judicial review.