Skip to content

Court Rules Chest Press and Trouser Removal Not Rape Attempt in Bihar Case

By News Analysis India · · 1 min read

In a significant legal development, the Patna High Court has clarified the scope of Section 376 of the Indian Penal Code. The bench examined the alleged actions of a studio owner who was accused of pressing a young woman's chest and attempting to unfasten her salwar during an incident in Banga district.

The court concluded that while these actions undeniably constitute an offence of outraging a woman's modesty under Section 354, they do not meet the statutory definition of an attempted rape. The distinction hinges on the presence of a direct act aimed at sexual penetration, which the prosecution could not prove due to the lack of medical documentation and contradictory witness statements.

The lower court had sentenced the accused, Himanshu Kumar Patak, to three years of rigorous imprisonment and a monetary fine. However, the high court dismissed the conviction, citing procedural flaws in the investigation, such as the failure to record the forensic examination and the omission of crucial testimonies from the victim's mother and an independent local witness.

Justice Purnendu Singh noted that the legal threshold for an attempt at rape requires a clear, unequivocal act that pursues penetration, accompanied by supporting evidence. The act of forcibly keeping the victim in a studio and trying to remove her clothing, though morally reprehensible, falls short of this threshold.

This judgment contributes to an evolving legal landscape in India where courts are increasingly demanding concrete proof for serious sexual offence charges, separating moral outrage from statutory rape attempts.