Bike Seized Without Notice: Patna Panel Orders Relief for Buyer
In a significant decision, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in Patna has held that repossessing a two-wheeler for loan default without following the due legal process constitutes deficiency in service. The ruling comes in favour of Saurabh Raj, who approached the commission after his motorcycle was taken away by a financier.
The commission has ordered the financier to restore the motorcycle after a complete service, so that it is in roadworthy condition. In addition, the financier must pay Rs 10,000 as compensation for the mental anguish and physical harassment suffered by the complainant, and another Rs 10,000 towards the cost of the legal proceedings.
The background of the dispute dates back to July 31, 2013, when the complainant bought a motorcycle. To finance the purchase, he borrowed Rs 65,000 from the financier. The loan was structured as 20 monthly instalments of Rs 3,245 each. After the complainant defaulted on payments, the financier seized the vehicle on August 18, 2014, acting through the concerned parties. The complainant alleged that the statutory notice procedure had not been observed before the bike was taken.
While examining the matter, the commission focused on the sequence of notices that is expected before repossession. These include a notice demanding the outstanding dues, a loan recall notice, and a notice indicating the intention to seize the vehicle. The financier was unable to present the notice of intention to seize. The commission found this to be a clear lapse and ruled in the complainant's favour.
The commission has set a deadline of 120 days from the receipt of the order copy for the motorcycle to be serviced and returned, along with the payment of compensation and costs. Should the financier miss this deadline, the sums due will attract simple interest at the rate of 12 percent per year. The interest will run from the expiry of three months until the money is paid or the vehicle is handed over.
The commission has also made clear that if the motorcycle is not returned in running condition, the financier will have to pay Rs 50,000 as the cost of the vehicle. The decision was issued by Prem Ranjan Mishra, President, and Rajneesh Kumar, Member, of the commission.