Art 370 and PoK are the result of Lord Mountbatten’s hided enmity with Nehru due to his romance with Edwina
Art 370 and PoK: Mountbatten stabbed on the back of India with Kashmir interest via Nehru and Seikh Abdullah
Independence to Accession: Mohan Krishen Teng in the chapter 2 of his book ‘Kashmir, Article 370’ writes: “Mountbatten had several meetings with Maharaja Hari Singh and told the Maharaja that independence of the State was not a "feasible proposition". However, he conveyed to the Maharaja that in view of the Muslim majority of the population of the State and its geographical conditions, accession to India would not be in the interests of the Maharaja. Hari Singh was shocked because he had seen what Pakistan had wrought in the Punjab and thousands of Hindus and Sighs who had escaped from death had taken refuge in his State. Accession to Pakistan was the last act he was prepared to accomplish. He refused to open his mind to the Viceroy when the latter wanted to know what the Maharaja had decided about his future. He sought a meeting with the Maharaja the day he returned to the Indian capital, the Maharaja feigned illness and expressed his inability to talk to the Viceory. Moutbatten left the State high and dry,”
Here it should also be noted that on the suggestion of Lord Mountbatten Kishmir issue was taken into United Nation by J L Nehru. In fact Lord Mountbatten wanted to take revenge with J L Nehuru for his unethical romantic relation with Edwina Mountbatten. Lord Mountbatten took this revenge by confounding the clear sighted Kashmir issue. PoK and Article 370 are the result of that hided enmity in the heart of Lord Mountbatten for her wife Edwina’s romance with J L Nehru.
At rediff.com, on June 16, 2004; Claude Arpi, the well-known Tibet and Kashmir expert, analyses how Nehru's obsession with the politics of his ancestral state eventually bequeathed a festering problem for the whole of India.
India's first prime minister passed away 40 years ago; it should be time to assess his 17 years in office. Unfortunately, historians and researchers have never been allowed access to original materials to write about Nehru's leadership during the troubled years after Independence. It is tragic that the famous 'Nehru Papers' are jealously locked away in the Nehru Memorial Library. They are, in fact, the property of his family!
I find it even more regrettable that during its six years in power, the NDA government, often accused of trying to rewrite history, did not take any action to rectify this anomaly. Possibly they were not interested in recent history!
Apart from Nehru's official correspondence and notes, government reports such as the Henderson-Brookes Report (see earlier article, The Confiscation of History) are still classified more than 40 years after they were written. Some pretend that if published it would be too damaging for India's security. It is just laughable!
As a result, today history lovers and serious researchers have only the 31 volumes published so far of the Selected Works of Jawaharlal Nehru (covering the period 1946 to 1955) to fall back on. This could be considered a partial declassification of the Nehru Papers, except for the fact that the editing has always been undertaken by Nehruvian historians, making at times the selection tainted. The other problem is that these volumes cover only the writings (or sayings) of Nehru; notes or letters of other officials or dignitaries which triggered Nehru's answers are only briefly and unsatisfactorily resumed in footnotes.
With these limitations in mind, it is interesting to try to assess Nehru's role in the Kashmir question. Fifty-seven years after Independence, it has remained an unsolved (if not a 'core') issue for the subcontinent.
Everything started in early 1946 when the Indian National Congress had to elect a new president. It was an accepted fact that the leader chosen as Congress president would become the first prime minister of independent India. Three candidates were in the race: Acharya Kripalani, Jawaharlal Nehru, and Sardar Patel. The working committee of the INC and the pradesh committees had to send their nomination for one of the three candidates.
Sardar Patel was easily the most popular. Everyone knew his efficiency and his toughness for tackling difficult problems. Twelve out of 19 Pradesh committees nominated him. None nominated Nehru.
From the start Gandhi had indicated that he favoured Nehru. His reasoning was that his British education was an asset: 'Jawaharlal cannot be replaced today whilst the charge is being taken from the British. He, a Harrow boy, a Cambridge graduate, and a barrister, is wanted to carry on the negotiations with the Englishmen.'
Another point Gandhi made was that while Sardar Patel would agree to work as Nehru's deputy, the reverse might not happen. He also felt that Nehru was better known abroad and could help India play a role in international affairs.
Eventually, in deference to Gandhi, Kripalani nominated Nehru and withdrew from the race. Patel had no choice but to follow his colleague 'so that Nehru could be elected unopposed.' Dr Rajendra Prasad later stated: 'Gandhi has once again sacrificed his trusted lieutenant for the sake of the glamorous Nehru.'
It is how India got a Kashmiri Pandit as its first prime minister.
I have always found it strange that a man professing to be above caste or religion agreed to be called 'Panditji.' Nonetheless, the fact that a Pandit was the prime minister made Kashmir a state different from the 500 other princely states.
Soon, the conflicting aspects in Nehru's persona came to the fore. On one hand, he was a democrat and revolutionary; on the other, he was often carried away by his 'Socialist' ideals to the point of blundering with India's destiny.
After his election as Congress president, he gave his support to his friend Sheikh Abdullah (he called him his 'blood brother') who had been jailed by Maharaja Hari Singh of Kashmir. In June 1946, he decided to go to the valley to free Abdullah. The situation was certainly not shining in Kashmir (as in the rest of India), but to take on the maharaja at this point in time was a serious mistake.
However, for Nehru, 'Anything that happens in Kashmir has a certain importance for the rest of India, but recent events there have had an even greater importance, [they] became symbols of a larger struggle for emancipation. Thus Kashmir became symbolic of the [princely] States in India.' He wanted to take on 'the autocratic and often feudal rule that prevails there.' He did not realise that the princes' support and collaboration would be indispensable during this all-important transition period for the nation.
Though prohibited to enter the maharaja's state, in July 1946 Nehru decided to defy the ban. Patel and other members of the working committee tried to dissuade him: there were more important matters to tackle in Delhi after the Cabinet Mission had come to discuss the transfer of power.
In a letter to D P Mishra, Patel explained: 'He [Nehru] has done many things recently which have caused us great embarrassment. His actions in Kashmir ... are acts of emotional insanity and it puts tremendous strain on us to set the matters right.' However, Patel, always fair, added: 'but in spite of all these innocent indiscretions he has unparalleled enthusiasm and a burning passion for freedom.' Patel, thus, pointed out the two powerful (and opposing) aspects of Nehru's personality.
A year later, hardly two weeks before Independence, Nehru still wanted to go to Srinagar. He wrote to Gandhi: 'I shall go ahead with my plans. As between visiting Kashmir when my people need me there and being prime minister, I prefer the former.' Once again he had to be dissuaded.
At the stroke of the midnight hour on August 14, India awakened to life and freedom. Unfortunately, Maharaja Hari Singh remembered the events of the previous year and while most princes signed the Instrument of Accession of their state to the Dominion of India, Hari Singh prevaricated. What would happen to him and his state under Nehru's rule? He also knew that the future of his state could not lie with Jinnah and his government.
In September, he decided to offer Kashmir's accession to India. This was refused by Nehru, who first wanted Sheikh Abdullah to be freed and installed as prime minister of the state. This was not acceptable to the maharaja.
Things came to a head at the end of October 1947 when raiders from the North West Frontier Province entered the state, killing, looting, and raping along. On October 26, they had reached the outskirts of Srinagar. Hari Singh agreed to sign the Instrument of Accession.
On the same day a historic meeting was held in Delhi with Mountbatten, the governor general, as chairman. A young army colonel named Sam Manekshaw, who attended the meeting, recalled: 'As usual Nehru talked about the United Nations, Russia, Africa, God Almighty, everybody, until Sardar Patel lost his temper. He said, 'Jawaharlal, do you want Kashmir, or do you want to give it away?' He [Nehru] said, 'Of course, I want Kashmir.' Then he [Patel] said: 'Please give your orders.'
This anecdote perfectly exemplifies Nehru, who could make the greatest speeches, but was unable to take a decision at a crucial moment. Thanks to Patel's decisiveness, troops were flown to Srinagar the next morning and the airport, the only link with India, was saved. Military operations to expel the raiders started.
Nehru's colleagues soon discovered they had made another serious blunder, a collective one. They had chosen Mountbatten to be the first governor general of independent India while Jinnah had kept the post for himself in Pakistan. At that time, it was probably easier for the Congress to have a foreigner as the head of the Dominion; it conveniently avoided having to choose among themselves. However, Mountbatten manipulated matters so well that he became chairman of a newly created defence council. Nehru did not see a problem in this: Mountbatten (and his wife) were his best friends.
But this was to have grave repercussions on Kashmir policy. Mountbatten, a British officer, was now at the helm of the executive defence machinery. British generals still serving in India reported to him. Mountbatten was not working for India's interests, but the British crown's.
Nehru's sentimental attachment to the Mountbattens deeply vitiated the Kashmir issue. It was certainly the most important factor for the failure to find a solution in the first years of the conflict.
Events took a turn for the worse at the end of December 1947 when the governor general managed to convince Nehru that India had to refer the Kashmir issue to the UN instead of conducting a military counterattack in West Punjab. Patel did not agree. But at this precise point in time the Sardar, who had so far looked after the relations with the princely states, was sidetracked. On December 23, he wrote his resignation, but was prevented (by Gandhi) from pressing for it. From that day, with Patel out of Kashmir affairs, things went from bad to worse.
In the first months of 1948, during the UN hearings, the British showed where their interests lay. The original Indian complaint was completely left aside and the Security Council began adopting anti-India resolutions.
Abdullah had already started his crusade (particularly with the US administration) for Kashmir's independence. He remained Nehru's friend till his scheming became too dangerous for India. In August 1953, he was finally dismissed by Karan Singh, the sadar-i-riyasat. Two months earlier, Shyama Prasad Mookerjee, who had been arrested by Abdullah and left without medical care in Srinagar, died in mysterious circumstances. Nehru had visited the capital of Kashmir a few days earlier, but did not find the time to call on his former Cabinet colleague. He later wrote to Mookerjee's mother: 'Indeed, I hoped that the healthy climate of Kashmir might lead to an improvement in Shyama Babu's health.'
Though in the following years Nehru hardened his position when different UN commissions (Dixon, Graham, Jarring) visited Delhi, it was too late. Pakistan was certainly not interested in vacating the so-called 'Azad Kashmir', rendering the plans for a plebiscite mentioned in the UN resolutions of August 1948 and January 1949 irrelevant.
A few days before his death Nehru sent a freshly released Abdullah to meet Ayub Khan with a proposal to have a confederation of India, Pakistan and Kashmir. The proposal was contemptuously rejected as 'absurd' by the Pakistani military ruler. It was Nehru's last attempt to solve the issue and it failed.
In retrospect, despite Nehru's love for great principles, his incapacity to take decisions in time, his inability to work with colleagues like Patel, and his friendship with individuals such as the Mounbattens or Abdullah, who had their own interests, blinded him so much that he did not further India's national interests. The consequences have been tragic and the muddle created 57 years ago remains far from being sorted out.
Very soon most probably in the first week of July 2014, my book on Article 370 is going into the press for publication. Your suggestion for the same is welcome.
I have published the book: Silent Assassins, Jan 11, 1966 (Assassin of Lal Bahadur Shastri)
The book is freely available to read at: http://www.scribd.com/doc/143635279/Silent-Assassins-Jan11-1966
You may visit us at:
Kashmir a paradise lost can be found again to abrogate Article 370
Kashmir Accedes to India: Oct 28, 1947: Hided facts behind Article 370
Hided facts behind Article 370: Maharaja Hari Singh’s Accession offer to India: Letter to Lord Mountbatten
Militants via Art 370 threw Kashmiri Pandits in the street of Delhi
Uniform Civil Code in BJP Manifesto: Respect for all religions in India’s DNA, said PM Modi
Justice Katju , belongs to Cong family, goes one step ahead of PM Modi in supporting the Uniform Civil Code
Does Congress spokesperson Tharoor oppose the debate on Uniform Civil Code due to ISI conspiracy?
Article 370 Time to review: Muslim Rashtriya Manch
Retweet & Breaking News: Article 370’s effect BBC's Modi coverage: Congratulates Modi in suicide note:: June 01
Article 370’s effect: BBC's Modi coverage as Dawood ISI’s Bol TV Pak channel
Depressed congratulates Modi in suicide note: His soul reminds NaMo’s- Era now is to live not to die
Super state vs Separate State: BJP now No 1 in J&K due to discussion on Art 370 by Modi in his Jammu Rally
Suspension of Mustafa due to Joker Rahul: Reinstating of 5 suspended DU officials due to Intelligent Smriti
Congress leaders should first read contradictory Election affidavits of Joker’s mother
Has Sheikh Abdullha dynasty birth right to revolt against India via Article 370?
Remembering May 16: Congress could not Change Name of India after the Dynasty, as named Rajiv Gandhi Airport?
Tendulkar, Rahul want to be in Text books vs Modi against move to include his life story in school curriculum
After AK-49, now thief of the Plaque with Savarkar's quotes at Andaman memorial should be in Tihar
Lord Macaulay’s clone-HRD Ministers of glass houses throw stones on Smriti Irani
Former MoS HRD Minister Dr Shashi Tharoor vs Smriti Irani
How did Sunanda Pushkar mysterious death link to Article 370 and ISI?
Bharat Mata got emotional to see N Sharif and N Modi in the laps of her two daughters India and Pakistan
Vendetta politics in Non-BJP ruled states Vs Modi for Nobody should be above the law
Modi to visit Rajghat epitaph Hē Ram: Ram Temple be built? Where is Ram Ring worn by Tipu Sultan?
Maryam proud of father Nawaz Sharif's decision to suspend his son-in-law Capt Safdar vs Vadra and Feroze Gandhi
Who washes the sin of UPA Govt? Ram-Ring worn by Tipu Sultan has gone in the hand of undisclosed buyer
Nawaz Sharif Wearing 4.9 million dollar watch & Free distributed Rahul Photo-watch
Think, how could AAP get 4 seats in Pujab only? Babbar Khalsa Terrorist Avtar Singh is arrested in Delhi!
Italina Product Priyanka Vadra is needed to fulfill last wish of Mahatma Gandhi to dissolve the Congress Party
14 day jail to Kejriwal, his Crime against Law of land & democracy is greater than Eco-Crime of Subrata Roy
AK-49 clone of Lalu gets divine knowledge to remain in Tihar Jail to adopt mediation with robber sinners
After arrest of Rahul with bag of dollar at Boston, Robert Vadra got VVIP status, now he is likely to be frisked at airports
Scaling Political Height of Kiran Kher and Kiran Bedi
Rahul wishes to shake hands with AK-49 in Tihar jail by saying Janata ki nahi suni gayi, toh aag laga denge
Why does AK-49 Kejriwal want to turn Tihar Jail into Parliament?
Honoring Farewell to Modi in Guj Assembly & dishonoring Farewell Party to Manmohan Singh by Sonia Gandhi
Returning Delhi of Narendra Modi as Ram in Ayodhya
Mugle Azam Khan says Muslims contributed to Modi's victory, proved them secular; otherwise they were communal
Nitish’s Renounce is greater than Sonia, appointed Manjhi as CM of Bihar to promote eating rat, why?
Caged PM Alias Caged CM: As Drama Queen Sonia renounced PM post, now Drama King Nitish renounces CM Post
Don’t throw Gold which is in Mobile scrap as silver in X-Ray films
Would Priyanka Vadra and Narendra Modi fulfill the last wish of Mahatma Gandhi to dissolve Congress?
Anti-national Aiyar who forfeited his deposit is disgrace to the sweeper profession
Conspiracy for underground support of Cong to Kejriwal in Varanasi and AAP to Rahul in Amethi
Ishrat’s father Nitish resigns: Lalu & AK-49 Kejriwal become the Political guru of Nitish, as Yogendra of Rahul Gandhi
Modi Victory March: AAP’s stone throwing on March 6 and flower rain flying white balloons on May 16 at Delhi BJP HQ
Recent most viewed articles:
Read Book by clicking here: Silent Assassins of Lal Bahadur Shastri, Jan 11-1966
Now in TN: Jaya vs Modi instead of Jaya vs Karunanidhi
Congress praises Vajpayee on website: Rahul, his girl friend arrested at Boston and became free due to Brijesh Mishra
Why did Nehru kidnap Feroze Gandhi’s wife? Spiritual Marriage vs vs Spiritual love
Kumar Vishwas chooses BJP over Congress: Does it mean he would Join BJP in future?
Anna – Kejri & co. spreading Anarchism in the speed of dog pees - Kukurmuttas to destabilize India
Antony reminds Unnatural death of Gandhis who had business rivalry for IAF deal
Kavitha daughter of KCR writes poem for TRS alliance with BJP as Chirag lighted lamp for LJP-BJP alliance
AAP’s Yogendra Yadav Political Guru of Rahul Gandhi: Maoists invade Congress
No difference between Mullah Zaeef and Prashant: What is hidden agenda of AAP and Cong on Kashmir?
States wants to destabilize India via Mullah Zaeef Prashant Bhushan Pakistan First activists
Why was 5 Star Aman choice? Gulam Nabi Azad-DLF-Vadra nexus behind AAP–Cong Marriage
AAP welcomes supporter of terrorist who wanted to Nuke Surat?
Ford Foundation of o a Italian village: Donation to Kejriwal who never utter against Sonia?
पढ़िएवाजपेयीजीकी२७कवितायेँ : Read 27 Poems of Atal Bihari Vajpayee:Ji
Prevention of Communal and Targeted Violence Bill to hammer unity-symbol of Loh Purush Patel
SUPREME COURT ON HINDU HINDUTVA AND HINDUISM
Gandhi vs Jinnah: India secular "because of Hindus"
Should FIR be filed against Chidambaram, Pawar, CBI and..
iGate Controvercial CEO Phaneesh Murthy: Scamsgate in Congress vs Sexgate in IT
Profile of Reka Maximovitch: Infosys vs Phaneesh Murthy
Assassins of Subhas Bose rule India now want to let killing of Modi?
Read 3000 worded Email of the Victim of Rapist Tarun Tejpal of Tehelka
Shshi Tharoor besides Mehr Tarar also with Hasiba of Cong ad Yuva Josh who did 300 Cr. Scam?
How did Sunanda Pushkar (tharoor) death link to IPL ISI Dawood?